Another typical junmai sake fueled rant....
Stop me if you've heard this one before:
Okay, so this biology professor in Kansas gets his butt kicked by two men offended by his recent e-mails where he derided 'intelligent' design. He now claims that he was forced to resign his professorship.
So sayeth CNN.com:
A recent e-mail from [Dr. Paul] Mirecki to members of a student organization referred to religious conservatives as "fundies" and said a course describing intelligent design as mythology would be a "nice slap in their big fat face." Mirecki apologized for those comments.
The actual e-mail was worded as so:
“Sent: Saturday, November 19, 2005
Subject: I.D. & Creationism class to be taught at KU this spring!
To my fellow damned,
Its true, the fundies have been wanting to get I.D. and creationism into the Kansas public schools, so I thought “why don’t I do it?”
I will teach the class, with several other lefty KU professors in the sciences and humanities. Class is:
REL 602 Special Topics in Religion: Intelligent Design, Creationisms and other Religious Mythologies.
Tuesdays 7:00-9:30pm. Smith Hall room 100. Open to undergrads and grads.
Enrollment limited to about 120. 3 credit hours.
The fundies want it all taught in a science class, but this will be a nice slap in their big fat face by teaching it as a religious studies class under the category “mythology”. I expect it will draw much media attention. The university public relations office will have a press release on it in a few weeks, I also have contacts at several regional newspapers.
Of course, I won’t actually be teaching I.D. and creationisms, but rather I’ll be teaching ABOUT I.D. and creationisms as modern mythologies, indicating that these ideas have no place in a public school science class, but can certainly be analyzed in humanities classes for their function in society. Basic approach is my usual: anthropology with a focus on religious thought and behavior.
Any ideas for textbooks, guest lecturers and panels would be appreciated.
So far, six faculty have eagerly signed up to lecture. I can probably pull Chancellor Hemenway into this also, especially in the light of his public comments supporting evolution.
Doing my part to p*ss of the religious right,
Evil Dr. P.“
Puerile and a bit childish? Of course. But not a beat-worthy offense. Nor was it an offense worthy of being fired. The thing that troubles me is that no one - not the school trying to save its own butt by turning on one of their own, not the professor in question, nor the ‘men’ who attacked him – no one has stopped to ask themselves a simple question: “Why?”
What is the point? The professor decided to take the low ground, and be insulting and childish. Web sites are already taking sides in this case and are trying to point out that creation-science websites are often full of lies, and scathing, vitriolic hatred of any who oppose their ideas. So… two wrongs now make a right?
The professor needs to take some responsibility. He used pointed, loaded language in an e-mail that only the truly stupid could have ever believed would be non-public. Being an educated man of science, he could have figured out a better way to open debate. He could have made a strong, scientific case for his opposition to ID and creation science. Could have, should have, would have. Whatever.
I have to admit that I tend to be hard on scientists and educators when it comes to issues of ethics. People who are leaders in their fields need to lead by example, and need to be the better person when dealing with those who oppose them. I am seriously disappointed with this professor. In an age where some religious leaders are too powerless to promote good and others just promote pure evil, we need genuine good leaders of the educational elite to act as role-models. Way to go for science! With friends like these you don’t need enemas.
(Just trying to see if you’re paying attention!).
And the school? Well, in typical Kansas “change-the-rules-as-you-go” fashion, they stabbed this guy in the back, rather than help him out and open dialogue between groups. Oh, and they cancelled the ID and creationism as mythology class too. To them I say - Bravo, folks. I’m disappointed in you as well for the reasons described in the above paragraphs. Grow a backbone. They’ve been around since the Cambrian. Oh, and that was a BIT longer than 6000 years ago.
And to the men who beat the professor? Wow! Boy, are YOU religious! If you believe in a devil, I’m sure he’s thanking you for doing his work. Way to be leaders! Way to set religion back 1000 years! I’m glad that the spirit of the 60’s is alive and well… Too bad it’s the 1860’s.
Am I wrong in just wanting a little more civility in the world?
Tired and annoyed, and drinking a sake toddy...
John