Need help with picking out filtration set up for 75 g tank, not sure what to use.

Deadly_Evolutio

Pygmy Octopus
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
I'm trying to figure out what type of filtration would be ideal to use for my upcoming octo tank. I plan to have some live rock, but not a whole lot, as obtaining 40 lbs is not cheap or easy in my area. So having an extra means of filtration is expected and probably required for an OCTO since they have a lot of waste?
So now my question, what would be a good method or 2 to pick between for filtration?
I was thinking plumbing something like a Fluval 405 into bulkheads drilled into the back of the tank? And having a simple sump tank under the stand mostly just to house the protein skimmer, and add water volume. Or should I looking into making a full on wet/dry refugium sump filtration? Bascially I don't want any over the top type devices. For this I was kind of looking at the Proflex Aqueon Refugium model 2. Or the Crystal Sump - Sump 30
 

SabrinaR

Larger Pacific Striped Octopus
Registered
Joined
Oct 2, 2009
Messages
1,462
Reaction score
7
As far as live rock goes normally that is the best method of filtration... I have heard pluses and minuses about both wet dry or refugiums. Setting up a refugium is pretty easy, a shop light, some macro algea and a bit of live rock rubble and youre in business... you shouldnt need the canister filter if your sump is set up right with a good high rated skimmer and refugium. IMO the best way to set up a sump is to have it split into 3 areas... skimmer-return-refugium. with at 75% 25% split with the water flowing into both skimmer side and refugium side.

I would look into getting live rock on craigslist. If you are near any major city you should be able to pick it up any where from 2-5$ a pound which is much cheaper than getting it from the store. You can also make it yourself which is a good way to help save the reefs. Go to youtube and type in making your own live rock. You should find many helpful videos.

Good luck and :welcome: to TONMO!
 

Deadly_Evolutio

Pygmy Octopus
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Thanks for the insite so far. So what about the bulkhead/tubing sizes for the inlet and outlet to the sump, what's the proper way to figure that out? Have not come across any info yet for this on the net.

Also is that your octo in your avatar pic?
 

SabrinaR

Larger Pacific Striped Octopus
Registered
Joined
Oct 2, 2009
Messages
1,462
Reaction score
7
Yes that was my octopus Isis. She passed away the day after Christmas... She was something else thats for sure. That picture right there is a solid reason to have a secure lid for your octopus tank. She got out of her tank when I left the tank durring feeding one day, after that she was never quite the same and passed about a month later.

As far as how to figure out rate and speed of pumps. You start with figuring out what size pump you need for your tank. It is recommind to have 10x the size of your tank. So if you have a 55 gallon tank you would multiply 55x10 and come to 550. So after that you would find a pump that has a 550 or more GPH (gallons per hour) rating the bulk heads and tubing size are based on two things. The Tubing size is based on the pump you have. Whatever pump you get will have an outlet hole for you to connect hose to it, that size will determine which size you will need. Bulk heads are pretty easy, you will normally need a a 1 or 1.5 inch bulkhead for holes. A 1 inch standard bulk head has at best a 600 gallon per hour flow rate though most people normally only have about 300 gallons per hour movement though a 1 inch bulk head. So a 1.5 inch bulkhead is recommind if you only have 1 overflow.

Many people have different ideas as to what is best in regards to setting up tanks and plumbing. If you have a local reef club thats pretty active you might try joining that way you could have some local help if you ever need it. I am by no means an expert when it comes to setting up plumbing so research research research is important.
 

DWhatley

Kraken
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
20,612
Reaction score
1,799
Location
Gainesville, GA
With as much water as you will be moving, I STRONGLY recommend two overflow bulkheads, each capable of handling the flow of the pump. It does not take much to slow down a return line (though they typically don't get fully blocked). My 65 has only one return and I have had issues with air in the line and quickly rising water. If the power goes out, I will almost always lose water to the floor when the pump starts back up until the air bubble clears (part of this is an oddity with the tank design but if we had used two bulkheads it would not be a problem). We even put two returns in Monty's 45 :biggrin2:
 

Deadly_Evolutio

Pygmy Octopus
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
dwhatley;169382 said:
With as much water as you will be moving, I STRONGLY recommend two overflow bulkheads, each capable of handling the flow of the pump. It does not take much to slow down a return line (though they typically don't get fully blocked). My 65 has only one return and I have had issues with air in the line and quickly rising water. If the power goes out, I will almost always lose water to the floor when the pump starts back up until the air bubble clears (part of this is an oddity with the tank design but if we had used two bulkheads it would not be a problem). We even put two returns in Monty's 45 :biggrin2:
So are you saying I want two sump pumps in case one gets clogged? Otherwise I'm not understanding. Also why would you loose water to the floor? Is your sump inlet pipe not positioned in a way that the sump volume can take up the extra man tank water until you reach the pipe or bulkhead position on the tank?

I'd love to see pics of your set ups for sump bulkhead locations.
 

DWhatley

Kraken
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
20,612
Reaction score
1,799
Location
Gainesville, GA
No, the other way around. You want two lines to the SUMP and one from the pump to the main tank. The reason I get water on the floor is somewhat complex due to the odd nature of this tank but essentially, the bulkhead that returns the water to the sump gets an air bubble, slowing down the water flow back to the sump so water is being pumped into the tank faster than it can flow out. If we had had two bulkheads for the water flowing to the sump, the slow down would not cause the water to rise in the tank. As a matter of detail, in this case, the water rises into an area that has been cut away (by the manufacturer) gets between the glass and the frame but even without the oddities of this tank, a similar problem in any tank may let the water rise to an overflow condition. Something as simple as a snail in the drain line can cause an overflow so having two reduces the chances to almost 0.

The tank talk (this) forum has photos of most of our build outs as well as some nice shots of other members' setups.
 

Deadly_Evolutio

Pygmy Octopus
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
dwhatley;169459 said:
No, the other way around. You want two lines to the SUMP and one from the pump to the main tank. The reason I get water on the floor is somewhat complex due to the odd nature of this tank but essentially, the bulkhead that returns the water to the sump gets an air bubble, slowing down the water flow back to the sump so water is being pumped into the tank faster than it can flow out. If we had had two bulkheads for the water flowing to the sump, the slow down would not cause the water to rise in the tank. As a matter of detail, in this case, the water rises into an area that has been cut away (by the manufacturer) gets between the glass and the frame but even without the oddities of this tank, a similar problem in any tank may let the water rise to an overflow condition. Something as simple as a snail in the drain line can cause an overflow so having two reduces the chances to almost 0.

The tank talk (this) forum has photos of most of our build outs as well as some nice shots of other members' setups.
Ok, so two inlets and a single return for in case a 75 g tank, about 750 gph flow.
I"d "like" to do two 1" bulk heads for inlets (just due to space and size) and single 1" return, but that won't be enough return flow? I guess if I have to a 1.5" return could work.


Also I'm having trouble finding the tank set up thread, or at least the pictures. I went through about 20 pages and the stickies only found 2 tank set ups.
 

SabrinaR

Larger Pacific Striped Octopus
Registered
Joined
Oct 2, 2009
Messages
1,462
Reaction score
7
Another reason we like a 1.5" return is the way the water returns to the sump causes more O2 to get into the water... O2 is VERY important. I remember one time when Isis was acting very odd... not like herself at all. Well this went on for a little while and I went to search for a cause. The water was fine but when I checked the equipment it turned out the airstone that I had in the water was out because of evaporation. The second I put it back in the water she was acting like her old self again.
 

Deadly_Evolutio

Pygmy Octopus
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
sk252006;169465 said:
Another reason we like a 1.5" return is the way the water returns to the sump causes more O2 to get into the water... O2 is VERY important. I remember one time when Isis was acting very odd... not like herself at all. Well this went on for a little while and I went to search for a cause. The water was fine but when I checked the equipment it turned out the airstone that I had in the water was out because of evaporation. The second I put it back in the water she was acting like her old self again.
I read that thread of yours actually a few weeks ago. And I'm sorry for your loss of Isis, such an amazing creature, just love the avatar pic, which is why I had to ask if that was your octo. I do have another question for you if that is ok.
Ok so if I were to do two 1" sump inlets, and a single 1.5" return, (or if I did 1.5" for all 3) what controls the inlet and outlet flow. I mean it does not seem like a "perfect" match for incoming and returning water, is the use of a valve on each ok to balance this out?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
19,989
Messages
204,264
Members
8,844
Latest member
oslando33

Monty Awards

TONMOCON IV (2011): Terri
TONMOCON V (2013): Jean
TONMOCON VI (2015): Taollan
TONMOCON VII (2018): ekocak

About the Monty Awards
Top